Games Analysis |OT| Time To Argue About Pixels And Frames!

I think it just something that will start to get used once we get out of the launch line up and developers have more time with the hardware and out of this hectic period.

This is why I wouldn’t be too bothered about Series S missing out on certain features potentially or some compromises. It is the same cost as a Series S, so one should expect compromises. Developers just need to ensure that a Series S user is getting a decent experience that is similar to the Series X.

1 Like

It won’t be a hardware bottleneck. You are talking very small differences here and it may simply be the PS5 profiling for DRS is a bit better than that on the Xbox hence it showing up in the 120FPS modes.

1 Like

Yep. It’s related to SFS. I believe that’s the tie-in with why GPU intensive scenes are causing it to suffer more than PS5 in other games. PS5s brute force IO accomplishes a similar efficiency in off-loading work from the CPU for decompression. I’m not a dev or insider so this is all speculation on my part…but it fits logically.

1 Like

Technically, it’s the second. It performs better in 3 of the 4 modes in DMC:V

2 Likes

Yeah, it has no business being as good as it is at that price, lol.

Makes you wonder which games are fully using Velocity Architecture - as in SFS, Direct Storage and the hardware decompression block. Not many I bet at this early stage, not even for 1st party content, let alone 3rd party.

If that’s the case then XSX has had one hand tied behind its back, before considering the API performance issues.

1 Like

I hope Cyberpunk 2077 performs as great as CoD. I know we will probably start with a 30fps mode until next gen upgrade hits but I want that to be near locked and with great imagequality at least

Of course they did, lol. All of their major architectural decisions are based on mountains of data from PIX profiling and other internal testing. It’s literally just a handful of titles out of around 4000 available that aren’t living up to the expectation and those are all cross gen titles put together in a pandemic with extremely limited GDK functionality and targeting a console launch.

Here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=teNuT6UO1II

2 Likes

Did Witcher 3 launch with the performance mode or was that something they added when One X came out? I believe it never had performance mode at game launch, right?

Still, I hope they have a option for unlocked framerate. Even if it’s not a constant 60fps or frame pacing like KH3 has because VRR makes short work of that!!!

1 Like

Yep and DMC5 was most likely a rushjob as well.

Let’s see how much those banderas gifs will last. :stuck_out_tongue: :wink:

1 Like

A GTX 1650 mobile will run Black Ops Cold War from 30-53FPS at 1080p on medium settings with no RT. Just looked up buying a laptop with that spec -£600 ish. The Series S costs way under half. And runs the game way way better. It’s a marvellous machine that I’m enjoying a lot and is easily the best value gaming device I’ve ever bought. And COD runs very smoothly on it. Frankly people don’t have a clue what they are saying when they complain about it.

2 Likes

they added performance mode and HDR for Witcher 3 when Xbox One X came out.

As a total layman it seems that the series s would be much more effected by the immature Dev tools than the X. Due to its lower power it really needs all the bells and whistles of RDNA 2 in order to make up the difference.

The second thing that occured to me us that testing must be insane these days. A game like dirt 5 not only has multiple different versions but also 3 different performance modes. When the Xbox one launched there were 4 different versions to be tested on cross gen games. Now there are 17? different versions assuming the last gen games have 2 modes. That’s 4 times as many versions that need to be tested in a pandemic. Is it any wonder that games are launching with issues.

It is also a testament to just how good the ps5 tools are right now. It wouldn’t surprise me if their PS3 issues galvanized them. Microsoft seem to have prioritised hardware this time.

Great to see XSX showing strength with RT on CoD! The game is great and looks amazing

1 Like

There ain’t really anything special about PS5’s dev tools afaik. The ‘good’ there is that they are just same tools as PS4 had but with some next gen features exposed. That’s what you’d expect at bare minimum for a dev kit that only has PS4/PS5 platform targets. The PS3 definitely did galvanize Sony to make better dev environment catering to devs for PS4 and that is the same environment for PS5.

GDK targets X1/X1S/X1X/XSS/XSX/PC/xCloud all with shared codebase. Where it is lacking atm is in its next gen specific features. XSS was very carefully designed to rely on these next gen features, which is why it struggles more with the GDK’s next gen tools being immature atm. It sounds like XSX struggles due to devs not leveraging SFS yet, which leads to huge texture files streaming in that the CPU has to decompress, which leads to slightly worse framerates than PS5 in many cases.

Testing for cross gen is super demanding. Almost unimaginably so tbh. Not only are games like Valhalla wildly large and nigh impossible to fully test/debug in ideal conditions, imagine doing that on a time crunch to hit launch and doing so on X1/X1X/XSS/XSX/PC/PS5…all while much of the QA team is working remotely and might not even have ideal TV’s to test with, etc. Dirt 5’s tech director noted that the 120fps mode was not something they could feasibly test very thoroughly since he was only one who had much access to a 4k/120fps TV and everyone was working remotely, so they couldn’t just bring ppl into dedicated testing environment at the office. Devs are doing good work, all things considered.

Just watched the COD analysis and comparison video.

The 120FPS seems to be equal with both consoles dipping up to 20FPS but still at 100FPS or higher at all times. The 60FPS with Ray Tracing mode is where Series X dominates. Pretty much a consistently locked 60FPS.

1 Like

cyberpunk launching 30fps? If so I might have to wait for next gen version

Yep first “victory” for Xbox series x

1 Like

The seriesX has a more powerful GPU and higher memory bandwidth, logically it should perform. Better, this was the case last gen with the OG and mid gen consoles, so its nice to see the SeriesX pull ahead more with Cod:cold war.

If PS5 is better at 100+ fps at lower resolution it will become less and less relevant because after crossgen games wont target 120fps the vast majority of the time.

Yea I can definitely see 60fps being more of the norm or at least the option of it